Post image for Literary Movements: Insider as Outsider and Token Renegade

Literary Movements: Insider as Outsider and Token Renegade

Literary Movements: Insider as Outsider and Token Renegade

by Joe Weil on December 29, 2010

When gaining a foothold among the establishment, it is important the so called “outsiders” or mavericks have a figure fully anchored within the establishment who can be “acceptable” to the degree that he is:

1. Friendly to their cause, or, at the least, suffers their presence gladly.

2. Perceives himself (or herself) as being “forward thinking” (it does not matter if he or she is truly forward thinking as long as he or she considers his or herself as having a nose for future value).

3. Often someone with disposable income or privilege fully willing to dispose of it.

4. A disgruntled, black sheep member or son or daughter of the highest inner circles willing to defect and lend their support and contacts and influence to the “new” order.

In terms of the Black Mountain school let’s fill out that order. William Carlos Williams, especially in his more objectivist, socialist form was perceived as friendly to the cause of poetic innovation, and was enough of an outside/insider to prove acceptable as a substitute for Eliot whose triumphant followers in the form of the post-war formalists, and metaphysical poets had a lock on academic positions and public adoration. As the Agrarians had done twenty years before, the Black mountain school found a camp in the wilderness, but, unlike the agrarians (John Crowe Ransom, Robert Penn Warren, Allen Tate, etc, etc) they did not embrace a local, southern aesthetic, but used the isolated camp in the mountains of North Carolina as a meeting ground for international figures of the “new.” The romance of this camp caught the imagination of one of the most “inside” figures in all of poetry: Robert Lowell. Lowell, bi-polar and supremely gifted, and from one of the most powerful and gloried families in New England, was the chief darling, along with Randal Jarrell of the late thirties and early forties elders. In post-war poetry, he was dominant.

His “conversion” to free verse and to writing from life in mid to late fifties put a stamp of approval upon what had been the outsider’s position. I forgot to mention the idea of the “sacrificial lamb” or “innocent victim” around which the outsiders rally, and thereby seize power. In this case, the most comical, and unlikely lamb in literary history: Ezra Pound. Lowell’s championing of Pound, and the defense of Pound, the fight to get Pound out of jail for treason, brought Williams, Pound’s college buddy, and the Black mountain school, as well as Lowell into alliance, putting the final seal of “greatness” on Williams which had begun with Jarell’s introduction to his selected poems, and the rich James Laughlin’s interest in publishing Williams’ work,  This rallying around Ezra brought certain poets into prominence much as the Vietnam war protests of the sixties brought Bly, Merwin, and the Deep Imagists to the fore. So that’s the other condition for outsiders becoming the insiders: a proper “victim” or martyr they can rally around. (“Free Mumia” t-shirt anyone?)

We will be studying these mechanisms in detail through both the poems and essays in the following movements:

1. First and second generation romantics.
2. The Imagists.
3. The Black Mountain school
4. The Beats/ San Francisco/Confessional schools
5. New York School/L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E/Surrealists
6. Deep Imagists
7. Multicultural (or the cannon warriors)
8. Gender, queer, and green theory

And their various alliances, misalliances, temporary marriages of convenience, hybrids, and finally:

9. Slam and spoken word, and its mixture of multi-cultural, beat, gender/queer identity and post-Lenny Bruce menology (as well as aspects of the self-acceptance movement).

Certain suppositions:

1. With the possible exception of spoken word and multiculturalism, none of these “mavericks” were truly outside the power structure, and all of them depended on converts within the power structure to gain a foot hold.
2. All movements, once gaining a foothold, take on the characteristics of power against which they rebelled, and the re-affirmation of elitist exclusion/inclusion tactics. All end up being part of the academic and publishing establishment, and are distilled beyond their original definitive traits into what I will call “establishment and normative” sea. All rivers run to the sea, and that sea is both the death of a dynamic, and the force of the power in all dynamics.

We will be studying these power games through certain theories of co-operative evolution, and one thing the evolutionists are never interested in and ought to be: the tendency of movements and isms to create abnormative, non-breeding “heroes”– not unlike priests who function in the realm of  what I will call “virtual mate selection” and produce “virtual” progeny. The way this is done bears many common traits with actual mate selection and the bearing/raising of children. So we will study these movements in relation to “courtship.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Asbury Park December 29, 2010 at 4:39 pm

Jarrell’s intro to WCW’s Selected was complimentary in a backhanded sort of way. By the time I read it, Williams’ rep thankfully didn’t need Jarrell’s tepid endorsement.

Pigsnout2 December 29, 2010 at 11:32 pm

Agreed and yet Williams was grateful, overly so. Jarrell was that powerful at the time, and it helped Laughlin’s press tremendously. Williams’ books before New Directions were all more or less co-operatives or self published. His book by Angel Flores had not sold at all. If you want a blow by blow account of Williams’ long struggle towards prominence, read a very complete book on the history of his critical reception by Paul Marianni. I found it in a library garbage bin a couple decades back and still find it both enjoyable and useful.. Back then, poets were to be reserved in their praise, and Williams was still considered a bit of a quack, and an under achiever– especially by his good buddy, Pound. Jarrell’s back handed intro should be seen in balance with its time. Charlotte Bronte’s apology for the crudity of Emily Bronte is even more shocking along those lines and Allen Tate absolutely betrayed and savaged his friend, Hart Crane. That was not a time for self-loving academics. Blood was on everyone’s lips, bite marks on everyone’s shoulders. Jarrell took a chance, but it was an easy chance since Laughlin was rich, and money talks on the poetry scene. Let’s not be stupid about it. Poets often attack the weak and kiss the ass of the strong. This is even more so in this age when only tenure allows poets to make a living.

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: